Header Logo
Home Newsletter Blog Coaching
About
About Laura Connect with Laura
Log In
← Back to all posts

PLN 25: What if defensiveness is actually useful?

Mar 25, 2026

Time to Read: 3 mins

I have a file called “Read Later” synced across all my devices.

It’s where I stash things that catch my attention… everything from articles, to quotes, to ideas I want to come back to.

And whenever I’ve got time to burn, like standing in crazy long lines at the airport 🤦‍♀️, I open it up.

And somehow, it always serves up the exact right thing, at the exact right moment.

This week, I found myself re-reading an old Atlantic article by Arthur Brooks, Changing Your Mind Can Make You Less Anxious.

And one line in particular grabbed me and wouldn’t let go:

“When your ideas are threatened and you feel defensive, actively reject your instinct to defend yourself, and become more open instead.”

Yep, the universe had my number and wasn't going to let me off the hook.

For context, a few days earlier, I had left a meeting feeling icky and off.

I was frustrated because I wasn’t able to get my point across, and instead of slowing down and digging deeper, I felt myself getting defensive and tightening up.

And the more defensive I became… the less I was actually listening to others.

And understanding their perspectives more deeply would’ve helped us all.

💡 Thankfully, Brooks’ article triggered an important a-ha! 💡

❌ Defensiveness isn’t the problem.

✅ It’s actually a signal.

It tells you that something you care about feels threatened.

And it reminds you that there’s something there worth paying attention to.

But in the moment, it’s easy to misread that signal.

We treat it like something to shut down, justify, or push through.

But the better approach is to take a step back and ask yourself, "What am I not seeing right now?"

Because being open doesn’t mean abandoning your position.

It means creating just enough space for your thinking to evolve.

And when you do so, your understanding, as well as your ability to find common ground with others, is strengthened.

But taking that step back isn’t always intuitive.


💡 Practionable Takeaway

So, the next time you feel that defensive edge, try this:

1️⃣ Get curious before you get certain.

Ask one question with the genuine intent to understand, and importantly, not respond. Curiosity has a way of softening the edges without forcing agreement.

2️⃣ Look for what challenges you.

Not just what confirms you. Even a few minutes spent exploring the “other side” can shift how you see both the situation, and the person across from you.

3️⃣ Separate what happened from how it felt.

Lay out the facts as clearly as you can. Then notice what you added to them. That distinction alone can change how you show up next.


🎥 Want to Go Deeper? 

That first step — getting curious before getting certain — is far more powerful than is often realized.

Because curiosity is one of 24 natural strengths we all possess, albeit to varying degrees.

What are the other 23?

And what level of each do you possess?

Find out in this week's video.👇

Stop Fixing Your Weaknesses. Start Using Your Strengths.

To Your Success,

Laura 💜🧡

Responses

Join the conversation
t("newsletters.loading")
Loading...

The Practionable Leader

Practical, Actionable Strategies to Cultivate Your Inner Leader for Outer Impact
PLN 40: Self-Leadership in the Age of AI: Why the Inner Work Still Matters Most
Time to Read: 4 mins  I was recently at a leadership event, and I did the thing we all pretend we don’t do. I eavesdropped. (Shhhh… don’t tell anyone.) 🤫 I was listening to a group of senior leaders who were deeply immersed in an AI conversation. And I was fascinated! They were talking about which tools they were testing, how they were wiring AI into their ecosystems, what they wanted to automa...
PLN 39: Content vs. Context: How the Best Leaders Listen
Time to Read: 4 mins  A client of mine had an awkward and tense conversation with one of their employees. 😬 As is often the case with these types of situations, it was actually the thing below the thing that was getting in the way. You see, my client left the conversation certain that they knew exactly what it was all about. In response, they took a hard position and were now defending it with ...
PLN 38: The drift nobody warns you about
Time to Read: 5 mins  I once worked with a leader we'll call "Rob." Rob started with nothing but an idea and tons of grit. Over the decades, he grew his idea into a profitable and highly respected company. It was a place where talented people lined up to work, and competitors clamored for his trade secrets. By any outside measure, he was a success story. But over the years, something drasticall...
Footer Logo
© 2026 Laura W. Miner | Practionable Leadership, LLC
Terms Privacy Policy Contact
Powered by Kajabi

Join Our Free Trial

Get started today before this once in a lifetime opportunity expires.